Down in the Elezar crypt - it really is a beautiful-looking room.
What can you tell us about Elezar?
This is a new restaurant in Mayfair that comes from Misha Zelman. If that name sounds familiar, it's because he was the man behind Zelman Meats and also one of the founders of Goodman. With Elezar, he's taken over a former church crypt and turned it into what he's calling an "Eastern European chophouse".
Mayfair crypt? That sounds familiar...
That's because it's taken over the same space that Brad Carter was once going to open as Undercroft (you can see him here inside the same space). That restaurant fell through on the route towards opening, and in a "no one saw this coming" moment, it was instead opened by Aldo Zilli. His restaurant also didn't last long and now, almost a year later, the space is finally being properly opened as Elezar as somewhere that finally feels like it'll be here for the long run.
Carter and Zilli's loss is clearly Zelman's gain, as he's inherited an absolutely stunning space, with vaulted ceilings and exposed brickwork making this a particularly beautiful restaurant. It's also surprising that with all that brickwork and concrete, the place isn't that noisy either, as those ceilings must be doing something to help (physics never was our strong point). It's also not his first time opening a spectacular underground space, as he also helped launch the subterranean Beast.
And where is this crypt exactly?
It's underneath a church that it's highly likely you've walked past in Mayfair at some point, the Grade 1 listed St George’s Church, which is just off Hanover Square. It's quite hard to miss.
Underneath this church is where you'll find Elezar (entrance on the right)
Once you track down the entrance, to the right of the church (there's a bouncer by it, which should make locating it easier), head downstairs to the restaurant. There is a small bar there too and we'd definitely recommend stopping there for a quick cocktail first.
The bar at Elezar, your first port of call.
And where should we sit?
It's quite a big space and pretty much any table in the restaurant looks decent. However, there are also some lovely-looking counter dining seats that look into the kitchen, if you prefer that kind of view over the Grade I architecture.
So what actually is an Eastern European chophouse, then?
Put simply, it's a steak and chop restaurant at the heart of it all, but everything that surrounds the main event is where the Eastern European elements make themselves known. That's particularly the case in the earlier parts of the menu, starting immediately with the bread, which is a must-order:
Bread with smalec (£4) - essentially a spread made from rendered pork fat, alongside another version of the same studded with crunchy pork bits. We could spend an entire meal eating this pork crack.
Another signature of the menu is their "zakuski", essentially bite-sized snacks that are here represented by thin slices of rye bread, topped with a slice of butter almost as thick as the bread and a choice of toppings. We went for:
Caviar and pork cheek zakuski (£21 and £7). The former is easy to cut into two and share, but we'd say to get one each of the pork version. Lovely as the caviar is, we leaned towards favouring the pork on this course.
After that, you have a choice of cold or hot starters with options like cured sea bream on the cold side or tongue on the hot side (that's big a "no thank you" from us on the latter, honestly). Here's what we went for:
Golumpki (cabbage roll, £14) - filled with fish, rice and paprika
One of the most obviously Eastern European dishes on the menu is the pierogi dumplings. These are the cheese and potato versions (we always like carbs with extra carbs).
Tuna tartare with crisps (£18) - simply served and a really generous portion too.
And then it's onto the chops?
Well, certainly the meat and fish part of the meal, anyway. This is where things start to get a little more straightforward, but it's also where you begin to notice that Elezar is pretty great value for money, particularly for such a prime location in the middle of Mayfair.
The main meat and fish cuts are all priced at £28, with options like fillet, skirt, pichana and Denver on the steak side, as well as pork chops, bream and tuna (the latter at £16 per 100g, mind). Even the more special "Elezar cuts" are great value. Those feature extra options like Australian wagyu, and while there's a budget-busting wagyu tomahawk with caviar at £280 that would serve three or four, we thought the following was extremely well priced:
Australian wagyu picanha (£34) - this is a generous portion of steak for that price. The steak was fabulous, the sauce was rich, and we loved the presentation.
Poussin Kyiv (£28) - moving away from the steak is this slightly deconstructed version of a chicken Kyiv that's absolutely swimming in garlic sauce.
And is there room for dessert after all that?
Not much, frankly. Options include an apple pie or a caramel flan, but we opted for an Eastern European classic.
Honey Cake (£9) - just right for sharing after all that meat.
What about drinks?
As we mentioned at the start, it's well worth stopping at the bar for a cocktail before starting. Vodka gets a lot of use in the cocktails, although they also have a martini section (mandatory these days), which is split between gin and vodka. They even do a Twinkle, something we don't see on menus enough these days. The cocktails are very good - but the martinis definitely need to be colder. There's a lot of space in that bar and we'd like to see them incorporating frozen glasses to really amp things up on the martini front.
As for wine, the European-focused list is split into regions and we'd definitely recommend getting some advice from their head of wine Merlin Ramos (previously encountered across the road at Humo) on making your way through it. His list here has a great entry-level price at £31, almost unheard of in a Mayfair restaurant, but it also caters for those who want to get a bit spendy, reaching up to £1400 for a 2000 bottle of Château Cheval Blanc Merlot.
Dacha Martini (Król I vodka, tomato, lemon, verjus, vermouth, £16) and a Twinkle Żubrówka bison grass vodka, Krupnik, elderflower, lemon, sparkling wine (£12). Good cocktails, very well priced, but a 6/10 on the cold scale for that martini.
Overall thoughts
We didn't quite know what to expect when we went to Elezar. What we found was a really beautiful-looking restaurant that was very surprisingly one of the best value meals we've encountered in Mayfair recently. The Eastern European elements also help to make it stand out from your standard steakhouse/chophouse. If you're looking for a special night out in Mayfair that won't leave your bank account in ruins, this really fits the bill.
More about Elezar
Where is it? The Vestry, 2A Mill Street, W1S 1FX
Find out more: Visit the website or follow them on Instagram @elezar.restaurant.
Hot Dinners ate as guests of Elezar. Prices are correct at the time of writing.
Subscribe to be the first to get the news from Hot Dinners








