The City

Barbecoa St Pauls

Barbecoa St Pauls


Critic reviews - total score 5.5 out of 10

Critics' score: 6 Zoe Williams Telegraph
Reviewed on August 07, 2011
"...bits of it are excellent, bits just good enough, but bits are so bad that it would be impossible not to mention them." READ REVIEW

 
Critics' score: 5 Jay Rayner Observer Estimated score
Reviewed on May 08, 2011
"If this restaurant opened in New York, its shortcomings would see it laughed out of town. I wish the presiding chef's home city really had been a huge influence." READ REVIEW

 
Critics' score: 6 Matthew Norman Telegraph
Reviewed on April 04, 2011
"'It’s irritating to have to say this,' said my friend, as we worked our way through a decent and inoffensively priced riesling, 'but this food is much too good for the venue.'" READ REVIEW

 
Critics' score: 5 John Lanchester Guardian Estimated score
Reviewed on January 29, 2011
"...Barbecoa is nowhere near the finished article. It feels like an experiment, and you, the customer, feel like the person who is being experimented on." READ REVIEW

 
Critics' score: 8 Richard Vines Bloomberg
Reviewed on January 04, 2011
"If meat is your thing -- and if you’re in the City, there’s a fair chance it is -- it’s worth setting aside the negativity that surrounded Barbecoa when it opened and recognizing it is a serious project of respected chefs." READ REVIEW

 
Critics' score: 5.5 John Wallsh Independent
Reviewed on December 18, 2010
"The war-zone aspect of Barbecoa is hard to love, but when it gets it right (as with the steak) you can forgive the slapdash approach to anything which isn't carnivore-related." READ REVIEW

 
Critics' score: 6 Marina O'Loughlin Metro
Reviewed on December 15, 2010
"I like most of the food a lot: crunchy, sticky ‘scratchings’ with an apple and mustard sauce; excellent pulled pork, a delicious, sweet-sour tangle of squidge and char with rich jalapeño cornbread and fresh, tart slaw." READ REVIEW

 
Critics' score: 3
Chris Pople Cheese & Biscuits
Reviewed on November 30, 2010
"I'd hesitate to dismiss the whole operation, as the front of house staff were really doing a great job and can't be held responsible for sourcing decisions made further up the chain, but I left Barbecoa with the impression that this was cheap food, cooked easily, marked up for a credulous city crowd, and served with the ever-present crutch of Oliver's popular branding." READ REVIEW

 
Critics' score: 6 Richard & Peter Harden's Estimated score
Reviewed on November 24, 2010
"When it finally arrived, the food was pretty good. A hearty cuisine-grand-mère–ish dish of pulled beef, for example, was thoroughly satisfying, and a huge bone-in steak was very decent too." READ REVIEW

 
Critics' score: 4 Fay Maschler Evening Standard
Reviewed by November 18, 2010
"The welcome managed to be both confused and glacial. Service flailed. Food, when it arrived, was tepid. Quantities veered between miserly for the high-end pricing and too much." READ REVIEW

 
Critics' score: 6 Guy Dimond Time Out
Reviewed on November 11, 2010
"Booking system apart, Barbecoa does many things right. It's a big, smart, City barbecue joint that proudly serves top-quality British meats from the attached butchery downstairs." READ REVIEW

 
Critics' score: 4 Herman Primero Dos Hermanos
Reviewed on November 10, 2010
"Anyone expecting anything to evoke BBQ from the US is going to be seriously disappointed." READ REVIEW

 
Critics' score: 8 Stephen Farmer View London
Reviewed on November 08, 2010
"The stunning views of one of the capital’s finest landmarks will probably get the majority of the plaudits but the quality of the food is every bit as impressive." READ REVIEW

 
Test

Restaurant details

Address: 20 New Change Passage, London EC4M 9AG

Telephone number: 020 3005 8555

Cuisine: American

Nearest station: St Paul's

  • Shop onsite
  • Takeaway available

 

Contact info

View restaurant website

Map

Swap Start/End
Powered by JReviews

Hot Dinners recommends

Test Drive

Hot Dinners on Instagram

0
Shares